diff options
Diffstat (limited to 'tests')
| -rw-r--r-- | tests/lean/Hashmap/Properties.lean | 9 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | tests/lean/Tutorial.lean | 389 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | tests/lean/lake-manifest.json | 44 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | tests/lean/lakefile.lean | 1 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | tests/lean/lean-toolchain | 2 |
5 files changed, 423 insertions, 22 deletions
diff --git a/tests/lean/Hashmap/Properties.lean b/tests/lean/Hashmap/Properties.lean index 6bc821d3..4db54316 100644 --- a/tests/lean/Hashmap/Properties.lean +++ b/tests/lean/Hashmap/Properties.lean @@ -330,12 +330,7 @@ theorem insert_no_resize_spec {α : Type} (hm : HashMap α) (key : Usize) (value simp_all simp [inv] at hinv int_tac - -- TODO: progress fails in command line mode with "index out of bounds" - -- and I have no idea how to fix this. The error happens after progress - -- introduced the new goals. It must be when we exit the "withApp", etc. - -- helpers. - -- progress as ⟨ z, hp ⟩ - have ⟨ z, hp ⟩ := Usize.add_spec hbounds + progress as ⟨ z, hp ⟩ simp [hp] else simp [*, Pure.pure] @@ -406,7 +401,7 @@ theorem insert_no_resize_spec {α : Type} (hm : HashMap α) (key : Usize) (value -- TODO: canonize addition by default? We need a tactic to simplify arithmetic equalities -- with addition and substractions ((ℤ, +) is a group or something - there should exist a tactic -- somewhere in mathlib?) - simp [Int.add_assoc, Int.add_comm, Int.add_left_comm] <;> + (try simp [Int.add_assoc, Int.add_comm, Int.add_left_comm]) <;> int_tac have hinv : inv nhm := by simp [inv] at * diff --git a/tests/lean/Tutorial.lean b/tests/lean/Tutorial.lean new file mode 100644 index 00000000..840a606e --- /dev/null +++ b/tests/lean/Tutorial.lean @@ -0,0 +1,389 @@ +/- A tutorial about using Lean to verify properties of programs generated by Aeneas -/ +import Base + +open Primitives +open Result + +namespace Tutorial + +/-#===========================================================================# + # + # Simple Arithmetic Example + # + #===========================================================================#-/ + +/- As a first example, let's consider the function below. + -/ + +def mul2_add1 (x : U32) : Result U32 := do + let x1 ← x + x + let x2 ← x1 + 1#u32 + ret x2 + +/- There are several things to note. + + # Machine integers + ================== + Because Rust programs manipulate machine integers which occupy a fixed + size in memory, we model integers by using types like [U32], which is + the type of integers which take their values between 0 and 2^32 - 1 (inclusive). + [1#u32] is simply the constant 1 (seen as a [U32]). + + You can see a definition or its type by using the [#print] and [#check] commands. + It is also possible to jump to definitions (right-click + "Go to Definition" + in VS Code). + + For instance, you can see below that [U32] is defined in terms of a more generic + type [Scalar] (just move the cursor to the [#print] command below). + + -/ +#print U32 -- This shows the definition of [U32] + +#check mul2_add1 -- This shows the type of [mul2_add1] +#print mul2_add1 -- This show the full definition of [mul2_add1] + +/- # Syntax + ======== + Because machine integers are bounded, arithmetic operations can fail, for instance + because of an overflow: this is the reason why the output of [mul2_add1] uses + the [Result] type. In particular, addition can fail. + + We use a lightweight "do"-notation to write code which calls potentially failing + functions. In practice, all our function bodies start with a [do] keyword, + which enables using this lightweight syntax. After the [do], instead of writing + let-bindings as [let x1 := ...], we write them as: [let x1 ← ...]. We also + have lightweight notations for common operations like the addition. + + For instance, in [let x1 ← x + x], the [x + x] expression desugars to + [Scalar.add x x] and the [let x1 ← ...] desugars to a call to [bind]. + + The definition of [bind x f] is worth investigating. It simply checks whether + [x : Result ...] successfully evaluates to some value, in which case it + calls [f] with this value, and propagates the error otherwise. See the output + of the [#print] command below. + + *Remark:* in order to type the left-arrow symbol [←] you can type: [\l]. Generally + speaking, your editor can tell you how to type the symbols you see in Lean + code. For instance in VS Code, you can simply hover your mouse over the + symbol and a pop-up window will open displaying all the information you need. + -/ +#print Primitives.bind + +/- We show a desugared version of [mul2_add1] below: we remove the syntactic + sugar, and inline the definition of [bind] to make the matches over the + results explicit. + -/ +def mul2_add1_desugared (x : U32) : Result U32 := + match Scalar.add x x with + | ret x1 => -- Success case + match Scalar.add x1 (U32.ofInt 1) with + | ret x2 => ret x2 + | error => error + | error => error -- Propagating the errors + +/- Now that we have seen how [mul2_add1] is defined precisely, we can prove + simple properties about it. For instance, what about proving that it evaluates + to [2 * x + 1]? + + We advise writing specifications in a Hoare-logic style, that is with + preconditions (requirements which must be satisfied by the inputs upon + calling the function) and postconditions (properties that we know about + the output after the function call). + + In the case of [mul2_add1] we could state the theorem as follows. + -/ + +theorem mul2_add1_spec + -- The input + (x : U32) + /- The precondition (we give it the name "h" to be able to refer to it in the proof). + We simply state that [2 * x + 1] must not overflow. + + The ↑ notation ("\u") is used to coerce values. Here, we coerce [x], which is + a bounded machine integer, to an unbounded mathematical integer, which is + easier to work with. Note that writing [↑x] is the same as writing [x.val]. + -/ + (h : 2 * ↑x + 1 ≤ U32.max) + /- The postcondition -/ + : ∃ y, mul2_add1 x = ret y ∧ -- The call succeeds + ↑ y = 2 * ↑x + (1 : Int) -- The output has the expected value + := by + /- The proof -/ + -- Start by a call to the rewriting tactic to reveal the body of [mul2_add1] + rw [mul2_add1] + /- Here we use the fact that if [x + x] doesn't overflow, then the addition + succeeds and returns the value we expect, as given by the theorem [U32.add_spec]. + Doing this properly requires a few manipulations: we need to instantiate + the theorem, introduce it in the context, destruct it to introduce [x1], etc. + We automate this with the [progress] tactic: [progress with th as ⟨ x1 .. ⟩] + uses theorem [th], instantiates it properly by looking at the goal, renames + the output to [x1] and further decomposes the postcondition of [th]. + + Note that it is possible to provide more inputs to name the assumptions + introduced by the postcondition (for instance: [as ⟨ x1, h ⟩]). + + If you look at the goal after the call to [progress], you wil see that: + - there is a new variable [x1] and an assumption stating that [↑x1 = ↑x + ↑x] + - the call [x + x] disappeared from the goal: we "progressed" by one step + + Remark: the theorem [U32.add_spec] actually has a precondition, namely that + the addition doesn't overflow. + In the present case, [progress] manages to prove this automatically by using + the fact that [2 * x + 1 < U32.max]. In case [progress] fails to prove a + precondition, it leaves it as a subgoal. + -/ + progress with U32.add_spec as ⟨ x1 ⟩ + /- We can call [progress] a second time for the second addition -/ + progress with U32.add_spec as ⟨ x2 ⟩ + /- We are now left with the remaining goal. We do this by calling the simplifier + then [scalar_tac], a tactic to solve arithmetic problems: + -/ + simp at * + scalar_tac + +/- The proof above works, but it can actually be simplified a bit. In particular, + it is a bit tedious to specify that [progress] should use [U32.add_spec], while + in most situations the theorem to use is obvious by looking at the function. + + For this reason, we provide the possibility of registering theorems in a database + so that [progress] can automatically look them up. This is done by marking + theorems with custom attributes, like [pspec] below. + + Theorems in the standard library like [U32.add_spec] have already been marked with such + attributes, meaning we don't need to tell [progress] to use them. + -/ +@[pspec] -- the [pspec] attribute saves the theorem in a database, for [progress] to use it +theorem mul2_add1_spec2 (x : U32) (h : 2 * ↑x + 1 ≤ U32.max) + : ∃ y, mul2_add1 x = ret y ∧ + ↑ y = 2 * ↑x + (1 : Int) + := by + rw [mul2_add1] + progress as ⟨ x1 .. ⟩ -- [progress] automatically lookups [U32.add_spec] + progress as ⟨ x2 .. ⟩ -- same + simp at *; scalar_tac + +/- Because we marked [mul2_add1_spec2] theorem with [pspec], [progress] can + now automatically look it up. For instance, below: + -/ +-- A dummy function which uses [mul2_add1] +def use_mul2_add1 (x : U32) (y : U32) : Result U32 := do + let x1 ← mul2_add1 x + x1 + y + +@[pspec] +theorem use_mul2_add1_spec (x : U32) (y : U32) (h : 2 * ↑x + 1 + ↑y ≤ U32.max) : + ∃ z, use_mul2_add1 x y = ret z ∧ + ↑z = 2 * ↑x + (1 : Int) + ↑y := by + rw [use_mul2_add1] + -- Here we use [progress] on [mul2_add1] + progress as ⟨ x1 .. ⟩ + progress as ⟨ z .. ⟩ + simp at *; scalar_tac + + +/-#===========================================================================# + # + # Recursion + # + #===========================================================================#-/ + +/- We can have a look at more complex examples, for example recursive functions. -/ + +/- A custom list type. + + Original Rust code: + ``` + pub enum CList<T> { + CCons(T, Box<CList<T>>), + CNil, + } + ``` +-/ +inductive CList (T : Type) := +| CCons : T → CList T → CList T +| CNil : CList T + +-- Open the [CList] namespace, so that we can write [CCons] instead of [CList.CCons] +open CList + +/- A function accessing the ith element of a list. + + Original Rust code: + ``` + pub fn list_nth<'a, T>(l: &'a CList<T>, i: u32) -> &'a T { + match l { + List::CCons(x, tl) => { + if i == 0 { + return x; + } else { + return list_nth(tl, i - 1); + } + } + List::CNil => { + panic!() + } + } + } + ``` + -/ +divergent def list_nth (T : Type) (l : CList T) (i : U32) : Result T := + match l with + | CCons x tl => + if i = 0#u32 + then ret x + else do + let i1 ← i - 1#u32 + list_nth T tl i1 + | CNil => fail Error.panic + +/- Conversion to Lean's standard list type. + + Note that because we use the suffix "CList.", we can use the notation [l.to_list] + if [l] has type [CList ...]. + -/ +def CList.to_list {α : Type} (x : CList α) : List α := + match x with + | CNil => [] + | CCons hd tl => hd :: tl.to_list + +/- Let's prove that [list_nth] indeed accesses the ith element of the list. + + Remark: the parameter [Inhabited T] tells us that we must have an instance of the + typeclass [Inhabited] for the type [T]. As of today we can only use [index] with + inhabited types, that is to say types which are not empty (i.e., for which it is + possible to construct a value - for instance, [Int] is inhabited because we can exhibit + the value [0: Int]). This is a technical detail. + + Remark: we didn't mention it before, but we advise always writing inequalities + in the same direction (that is: use [<] and not [>]), because it helps the simplifier. + More specifically, if you have the assumption that [x > y] in the context, the simplifier + may not be able to rewrite [y < x] to [⊤]. + -/ +theorem list_nth_spec {T : Type} [Inhabited T] (l : CList T) (i : U32) + -- Precondition: the index is in bounds + (h : ↑i < l.to_list.len) + -- Postcondition + : ∃ x, list_nth T l i = ret x ∧ + -- [x] is the ith element of [l] after conversion to [List] + x = l.to_list.index ↑i + := by + -- Here we have to be careful when unfolding the body of [list_nth]: we could + -- use the [simp] tactic, but it will sometimes loop on recursive definitions. + rw [list_nth] + -- Let's simply follow the structure of the function, by first matching on [l] + match l with + | CNil => + -- We can't get there: we can derive a contradiction from the precondition: + -- we have that [i < 0] (because [i < CNil.to_list.len]) and at the same + -- time [0 ≤ i] (because [i] is a [U32] unsigned integer). + -- First, let's simplify [to_list CNil] to [0] + simp [CList.to_list] at h + -- Proving we have a contradiction + scalar_tac + | CCons hd tl => + -- Simplify the match + simp only [] + -- Perform a case disjunction on [i]. + -- The notation [hi : ...] allows us to introduce an assumption in the + -- context, to remember the fact that in the branches we have [i = 0#u32] + -- and [¬ i = 0#u32]. + if hi: i = 0#u32 then + -- We can finish the proof simply by using the simplifier. + -- We decompose the proof into several calls on purpose, so that it is + -- easier to understand what is going on. + -- Simplify the condition and the [if then else] + simp [hi] + -- Prove the final equality + simp [CList.to_list] + else + -- The interesting branch + -- Simplify the condition and the [if then else] + simp [hi] + -- i0 := i - 1 + progress as ⟨ i1, hi1 ⟩ + -- [progress] can handle recursion + simp [CList.to_list] at h -- we need to simplify this inequality to prove the precondition + progress as ⟨ l1 ⟩ + -- Proving the postcondition + -- We need this to trigger the simplification of [index to.to_list i.val] + -- + -- Among other things, the call to [simp] below will apply the theorem + -- [List.index_nzero_cons], which has the precondition [i.val ≠ 0]. [simp] + -- can automatically use the assumptions/theorems we give it to prove + -- preconditions when applying rewriting lemmas. In the present case, + -- by giving it [*] as argument, we tell [simp] to use all the assumptions + -- to perform rewritings. In particular, it will use [i.val ≠ 0] to + -- apply [List.index_nzero_cons]. + have : i.val ≠ 0 := by scalar_tac -- Remark: [simp at hi] also works + simp [CList.to_list, *] + +/-#===========================================================================# + # + # Partial Functions + # + #===========================================================================#-/ + +/- Recursive functions may not terminate on all inputs. + + For instance, the function below only terminates on positive inputs (note + that we switched to signed integers), in which cases it behaves like the + identity. When we need to define such a potentially partial function, + we use the [divergent] keyword, which means that the function may diverge + (i.e., infinitely loop). + + We will skip the details of how [divergent] precisely handles non-termination. + All you need to know is that the [Result] type has actually 3 cases (we saw + the first 2 cases in the examples above): + - [ret]: successful computation + - [fail]: failure (panic because of overflow, etc.) + - [div]: the computation doesn't terminate + + If in a theorem we state and prove that: + ``` + ∃ y, i32_id x = ret x + ``` + we not only prove that the function doesn't fail, but also that it terminates. + + *Remark*: in practice, whenever Aeneas generates a recursive function, it + annotates it with the [divergent] keyword. + -/ +divergent def i32_id (x : I32) : Result I32 := + if x = 0#i32 then ret 0#i32 + else do + let x1 ← x - 1#i32 + let x2 ← i32_id x1 + x2 + 1#i32 + +/- We can easily prove that [i32_id] behaves like the identity on positive inputs -/ +theorem i32_id_spec (x : I32) (h : 0 ≤ x.val) : + ∃ y, i32_id x = ret y ∧ x.val = y.val := by + rw [i32_id] + if hx : x = 0#i32 then + simp_all + else + simp [hx] + -- x - 1 + progress as ⟨ x1 ⟩ + -- Recursive call + progress as ⟨ x2 ⟩ + -- x2 + 1 + progress + -- Postcondition + simp; scalar_tac +-- Below: we have to prove that the recursive call performed in the proof terminates. +-- Otherwise, we could prove any result we want by simply writing a theorem which +-- uses itself in the proof. +-- +-- We first specify a decreasing value. Here, we state that [x], seen as a natural number, +-- decreases at every recursive call. +termination_by i32_id_spec x _ => x.val.toNat +-- And we now have to prove that it indeed decreases - you can skip this for now. +decreasing_by + -- We first need to "massage" the goal (in practice, all the proofs of [decreasing_by] + -- should start with a call to [simp_wf]). + simp_wf + -- Finish the proof + have : 1 ≤ x.val := by scalar_tac + simp [Int.toNat_sub_of_le, *] + +end Tutorial diff --git a/tests/lean/lake-manifest.json b/tests/lean/lake-manifest.json index 94030cb6..5c20ec3b 100644 --- a/tests/lean/lake-manifest.json +++ b/tests/lean/lake-manifest.json @@ -1,40 +1,56 @@ -{"version": 4, +{"version": 5, "packagesDir": "lake-packages", "packages": [{"git": {"url": "https://github.com/EdAyers/ProofWidgets4", "subDir?": null, - "rev": "c43db94a8f495dad37829e9d7ad65483d68c86b8", + "rev": "a0c2cd0ac3245a0dade4f925bcfa97e06dd84229", + "opts": {}, "name": "proofwidgets", - "inputRev?": "v0.0.11"}}, - {"path": {"name": "Base", "dir": "./../../backends/lean"}}, + "inputRev?": "v0.0.13", + "inherited": true}}, + {"path": + {"opts": {}, + "name": "Base", + "inherited": false, + "dir": "./../../backends/lean"}}, {"git": {"url": "https://github.com/mhuisi/lean4-cli.git", "subDir?": null, - "rev": "5a858c32963b6b19be0d477a30a1f4b6c120be7e", + "rev": "21dac2e9cc7e3cf7da5800814787b833e680b2fd", + "opts": {}, "name": "Cli", - "inputRev?": "nightly"}}, + "inputRev?": "nightly", + "inherited": true}}, {"git": {"url": "https://github.com/leanprover-community/mathlib4.git", "subDir?": null, - "rev": "fa05951a270fef2873666c46f138e90338cd48d6", + "rev": "b639e46a19a0328adfb9b1fdf8cbe39dfc1de76b", + "opts": {}, "name": "mathlib", - "inputRev?": null}}, + "inputRev?": null, + "inherited": false}}, {"git": {"url": "https://github.com/gebner/quote4", "subDir?": null, - "rev": "c0d9516f44d07feee01c1103c8f2f7c24a822b55", + "rev": "e75daed95ad1c92af4e577fea95e234d7a8401c1", + "opts": {}, "name": "Qq", - "inputRev?": "master"}}, + "inputRev?": "master", + "inherited": true}}, {"git": {"url": "https://github.com/JLimperg/aesop", "subDir?": null, - "rev": "f04538ab6ad07642368cf11d2702acc0a9b4bcee", + "rev": "1a0cded2be292b5496e659b730d2accc742de098", + "opts": {}, "name": "aesop", - "inputRev?": "master"}}, + "inputRev?": "master", + "inherited": true}}, {"git": {"url": "https://github.com/leanprover/std4", "subDir?": null, - "rev": "dff883c55395438ae2a5c65ad5ddba084b600feb", + "rev": "ba5e5e3af519b4fc5221ad0fa4b2c87276f1d323", + "opts": {}, "name": "std", - "inputRev?": "main"}}]} + "inputRev?": "main", + "inherited": true}}]} diff --git a/tests/lean/lakefile.lean b/tests/lean/lakefile.lean index 1747c581..fef94971 100644 --- a/tests/lean/lakefile.lean +++ b/tests/lean/lakefile.lean @@ -8,6 +8,7 @@ require Base from "../../backends/lean" package «tests» {} +@[default_target] lean_lib tutorial @[default_target] lean_lib betreeMain @[default_target] lean_lib constants @[default_target] lean_lib external diff --git a/tests/lean/lean-toolchain b/tests/lean/lean-toolchain index 334c5053..fbca4d37 100644 --- a/tests/lean/lean-toolchain +++ b/tests/lean/lean-toolchain @@ -1 +1 @@ -leanprover/lean4:nightly-2023-07-12
\ No newline at end of file +leanprover/lean4:v4.0.0
\ No newline at end of file |